The Affordable Care Act and the Nurse Practitioner’s Liability

The Affordable Care Act and the Nurse Practitioner’s Liability

The two most common questions posed by our Nurse Practitioners are the following:

1)      Should I maintain my own separate limit or share a limit with the physician for whom I am working

2)      Do I purchase a claims made or occurrence policy.

Sharing Limits historically with the physician

In our experience, looking back over many years of insuring physicians who hire and supervise, work hand in hand with our Nurse Practitioners, the answer to that first question has been overwhelmingly SHARE limit with the supervising physician.

Experience in claims supports that the allocated settlements are not so large against the nurse practitioner, the liability ‘flows up to the highest credentialed, supervising physician.  This is the ‘Captain of the Ship’ Doctrine based on old Maritime Law.  The moment the discovery gets to the point of the protocol in the office establishing decisions and responsibility, the judge and juror’s begin to hold the physician’s accountable. 

And, the dynamic of holding the physician accountable alone, dismissing the Nurse Practitioner are changing. There are many more Nurse Practitioners entering the healthcare field.

The trend will bring about a change on physicians, their office protocol, the amount of time and effort and research into effective supervision in all specialties.

The Affordable Care Act and the Nurse Practitioner’s Liability

Because of the gradual introduction of as many as 30 Million Americans into the healthcare marketplace, the ancillary care providers will play a significantly higher profile role in the provision of primary and specialty services.

Whereas, this transaction between physician’s office and patient has been primarily between the physician and the patient, now the encounter will increasingly fall to the Nurse Practitioner.

There are over 150,000 Nurse Practitioners nationwide, according to the AA NP this is a steady increase of about 20 % in the last 10 years. Nurse Practitioners still must have a physician corroboration, or direct supervisorial relationship in many states, and, this trend is moving toward more independent care.

The profession is gradually taking on the role of primary care practitioner. These allied health professionals earn an average of almost $90,000 a year. The question of why a Midlevel practitioner  is sued is brought up often.

Supervision, communication and protocol

One of the biggest causes of these law suits is inadequate supervision or just no clear protocol (resulting in a Nurse Practitioner writing scrips, making decisions, establishing treatment plans without adequate contact with the physician collaborator. Midlevel providers and their employers are typically sued when the PA or NP practices beyond the scope of their training.

The Doctors’ Company Patient Safety Director  Robin Diamond, says that doctors need to remember to delegate with the awareness that the liability remains with the physician.

There are terrible stories of mis diagnosis, or under treating with adverse outcomes, resulting in a midlevel error costing the physician a large settlement.

Communication between NP and MD is paramount

Robin Diamond has written about this feeling of a mid-level provider, in the context of the busy practice. There are many factors which can result in the Nurse Practitioner causing a negligent situation, or to practice beyond the usual scope of training and education.

Why isn’t there more communication?

These are areas of focus for The Doctors’ Company in the coming years!

The Doctors’ Company insures and assists Nurse Practitioners

The Doctors’ Company Patient Safety specialty articles highlight articles so that the nurse practitioners insured by TDC can learn, discuss, implement changes to prevent bad outcomes.

There was a case where  a patient presented to the ED with a fracture that was misdiagnosed by the PA. "The patient never saw the physician, and he didn't even know the patient was in the hospital," this case in Tennessee produced this Supreme Court Decision:  "…. a supervising physician can be held vicariously liable for the negligence of his or her PA even if the physician never saw or treated the patient. This means that the doctor may automatically be held liable if the PA is found to have been negligent."

Occurrence or Claims Made: 

The question of claims made vs. Occurrence is somewhat related to these stories because it is likely that the malpractice policies carried by Nurse Practitioners are going to be long term and independent.  More and more opportunities for employment are presenting themselves to NP’s, independence, economy, innovation, there are a lot of dynamics supporting the long term growth of this niche within healthcare.

Purchasing a claims made policy is both less expensive in the short term and in the long term. I would recommend, for those Nurse Practitioners planning to work for five years or longer, as independents or business owners, carry your own claims made, separate policy.



You need to log in to comment.
  1. Re: Clinical Research Liability

    Do you recommend purchasing a tail insurance or a occurrence based insurance and add a tail policy afterwards...

    -- Ann Shang

  2. Re: Clinical Research Liability

    I am talking with a CTO in the US ( I am in US too) to be a contractor doing clinical trials on a part...

    -- Ann Shang

  3. Re: The Podiatrists Market Research Report states that demand for podiatrists will likely benefit from healthcare reform.

    My husband has been feeling a lot of pain in his feet recently. We think this could be due to his posture...

    -- Sarah

  4. Re: Developing Walk In and Urgent Care Centers

    It's good to see that urgent care facilities are becoming more and more prevalent. You are right that...

    -- Caden Dahl

  5. Re: Functional Medicine Malpractice Insurance

    Interested in obtaining information for FM MP

    -- Cynthia Shughrue

  6. Re: Visiting Residents/Intern/ Fellow (Hands On) Medical Malpractice Insurance

    I am a final year medical student planning to do a couple of electives in medical school in the US and...

    -- Varun

  7. Re: Medical Malpractice Insurance Benefits, expanding to outpatient facilities

    I like the idea of some of the cost returning to the normal discounted market after a few years of claims...

    -- Dave Anderson

  8. Re: Who Can Perform Liposuction Surgery?

    This is very interesting content! I have thoroughly enjoyed reading your points and have come to the...

    -- Re: Who Can Perform Liposuction Surgery?

    Thanks for helping me understand any licensed physician can actually perform this procedure as per the...

    -- Millie Hue

  9. Re: The Podiatrists Market Research Report states that demand for podiatrists will likely benefit from healthcare reform.

    Thanks for giving me more information about the benefits of podiatrists from the healthcare reform. ...

    -- James